My rudder is an early “prototype.” It was originally designed to fit the Com-Pac 19, and was cut down to fit my 16. I had IdaSailor cut it with a bit deeper draft than their normal Com-Pac 16 replacement rudder – it is a bit deeper than my keel, providing even better upwind performance and an early warning if I run the boat too shallow!
Overall this rudder has improved the performance of my 16 significantly. Tacks are much smoother without the frustrating loss of headway I found with my original flat plate rudder. Upwind performance has also noticeably improved.
Although I never had problems with excessive weather helm using my original rudder, I do notice that steering is more responsive than it had been with my old rudder. In sum, I’d argue that this is a necessary upgrade for any Com-Pac owner – and worth every penny!